Potito's Italian American Pastries Menu and Prices

Research and order delicious food from the up-to-date Potito’s Italian American Pastries menu. Find latest deals, prices, kid’s meals and more. Pick-up and delivery options available. Browse the whole menu or use our quick jump guide to go directly to the type section of the menu that you are looking for.

Potito’s Italian American Pastries Menu : Butter Cookies

Butter Cookies

Chocolate Drops Butter Cookies	$17.75 – $177.50	Price per pound.
Chocolate Jimmies Butter Cookies	$17.75 – $177.50	Price per pound.
Cinnamon Sticks Butter Cookies	$17.75 – $177.50	Price per pound.
Multi-Colored Jimmies Butter Cookies	$17.75 – $177.50	Price per pound.
Multi-Colored Shells Butter Cookies	$17.75 – $177.50	Price per pound.

Potito’s Italian American Pastries Menu : Italian Cookies

Italian Cookies

Anise Biscotti	$20.25 – $202.50	Your choice of 1, 3, 5, 7 or 10 lbs.
Amaretto	$20.25 – $202.50	Your choice of 1, 3, 5, 7 or 10 lbs.
Apricot Tops	$20.25 – $202.50	Your choice of 1, 3, 5, 7 or 10 lbs.
Baby Rings	$20.25 – $202.50	Your choice of 1, 3, 5, 7 or 10 lbs.
Chocolate Bars	$20.25 – $202.50	Your choice of 1, 3, 5, 7 or 10 lbs.
Coconut Macaroons	$20.25 – $202.50	Your choice of 1, 3, 5, 7 or 10 lbs.
Jelly Centers	$20.25 – $202.50	Your choice of 1, 3, 5, 7 or 10 lbs.
Long Johns	$20.25 – $202.50	Your choice of 1, 3, 5, 7 or 10 lbs.
Non-Peril Filled	$20.25 – $202.50	Your choice of 1, 3, 5, 7 or 10 lbs.
Nut Balls	$20.25 – $202.50	Your choice of 1, 3, 5, 7 or 10 lbs.
Nut Filled	$20.25 – $202.50	Your choice of 1, 3, 5, 7 or 10 lbs.
Plain Filled	$20.25 – $202.50	Your choice of 1, 3, 5, 7 or 10 lbs.
S-Cookies	$20.25 – $202.50	Your choice of 1, 3, 5, 7 or 10 lbs.
Scumetti	$20.25 – $202.50	Your choice of 1, 3, 5, 7 or 10 lbs.
Sesame Seed	$20.25 – $202.50	Your choice of 1, 3, 5, 7 or 10 lbs.
Zwieback	$20.25 – $202.50	Your choice of 1, 3, 5, 7 or 10 lbs.
Pignoli/Pastacini	$28.25	Price per pound.
Cherry Centers	$20.25 – $202.50	Your choice of 1, 3, 5, 7 or 10 lbs.

Potito’s Italian American Pastries Menu : American Pastries

American Pastries

Almond Horns	$3.25
Apple Crumb Danish	$2.00
Apple Strudel	$3.50
Apple Turnover	$3.50
Brownies	$2.50
Fruit Pockets	$2.25
Fruit/Cheese Cuts	$3.50
Hamatash	$2.25
Pig Ears	$2.95
Puff Danish	$2.25
Spice Cake	$2.50
Apple Dumplings	$3.25

Potito’s Italian American Pastries Menu : Italian Pastries

Italian Pastries

Baba Rum	$3.50
Baba Rum Filled
Banana Raspberry	$4.00
Cannoli	$3.75
Choc Cov/Tiramisu Cannoli	$5.25
Cream Puffs	$11.50
Creme Brulee	$3.50	Add chocolate for an additional charge.
Crostata	$4.00
Eclairs	$3.75
Fruit Cheesecake Cup	$4.00
Fruit Cups	$3.00
Ice Cream Sandwich	$6.00
Lobster Tail	$4.75
Mini Sfogtielle	$2.00
Napoleon	$3.75
Pastaciotti	$4.50
Ricotta Bar	$4.00
Sfogtielle	$4.00
Tiny Torte Cups	$3.25
Tiramisu Cups	$4.50
Turtle Cheesecake Cup	$4.00
Peaches	$4.00

Potito’s Italian American Pastries Menu : Cannoli

Cannoli

Cannoli Shells	$0.95 – $1.25	Your choie of a small or large
Vanilla Cream	$6.00	Price per pound.
Chocolate Cream	$6.00	Price per pound.
Ricotta Cheese	$7.25	Price per pound.
Colossal Cannoli	$114.95	Your choice of 5 dozen mini or 2 ? doz and 6lbs filling or 12 lbs filling.
Bambino Cannoli	$57.50	Your choice of 2 ? doz. mini or 15 mini and 3lbs filling or 6lbs filling.
Empty Bambino Shells	$23.00
Empty Colossal Shells	$46.00

Potito’s Italian American Pastries Menu : Danish

Danish

Mini Danish (Price per Dozen, Minimum 3)

$12.75

Potito’s Italian American Pastries Menu : Tortes

Tortes

Apple Tortes	$19.50
Choc. Cov. Tortes	$28.75
Mixed Fruit Tortes	$25.00
Strawberry Tortes	$27.50

Potito’s Italian American Pastries Menu : New York Cheese

New York Cheese

Choc. Shav New York Cheese	$20.75 – $39.75	Your choice of 6″ or 10″.
Creme Brulee New York Cheese	$12.95 – $35.75	Your choice of 6″ or 10″.
Fruit New York Cheese	$12.50 – $34.50	Your choice of 6″ or 10″.
Marble New York Cheese	$13.25 – $35.75	Your choice of 6″ or 10″.
Plain New York Cheese	$11.75 – $33.95
Choc Swirl New York Cheese	$13.25 – $35.75	Your choice of 6″ or 10″.
Choc Chip New York Cheese	$13.25 – $35.75	Your choice of 6″ or 10″.
Choc. Cake New York Cheese	$21.75 – $51.75	Your choice of 6″ or 10″.

Potito’s Italian American Pastries Menu : Santa Nore

Santa Nore

Santa Nore	$32.95 – $45.95	Your choice of a 8″ or 10″ cake.
Butter Cake	$13.75

Potito’s Italian American Pastries Menu : Cake Slices

Cake Slices

Slice of Carrot Cake	$3.50
Slice of Choc. Pb Ganache	$4.25
Slice of Chocolate Sbs	$3.50
Slice of Hawaiian Cakes	$5.75
Slice of N.Y. Cheese with Choc Cake	$4.25
Slice of Italian Cream	$4.25
Slice of N.Y. Cheese with Choc Mousse	$3.75
Slice of Peach Sbs	$3.50
Slice of Straw. Sponge Cakes	$6.25
Slice of Tarta Fata	$4.25
Slice of Tarta Fata	$4.25
Slice of Van Sbs	$3.25
Slice of Lemon Merigue	$3.75
Slice of Specialty Cheesecake	$4.50

Potito’s Italian American Pastries Menu : Cake Rolls

Cake Rolls

Chocolate Cake Roll	$8.75
Jelly Cake Roll	$8.25
Italian Rum Roll Cake Roll	$12.95
Lemon Cake Roll	$8.25
Strawberry Cake Roll	$13.25

Potito’s Italian American Pastries Menu : Cakes

Cakes

Italian Cream Cake	$30.99 – $204.25	Your choice of 8″, 9″, 10″, 12″, 14″, 1/4 sheet, 1/2 sheet or full sheet.
Red Velvet Cake	$30.99 – $204.25	Your choice of 8″, 9″, 10″, 12″, 14″, 1/4 sheet, 1/2 sheet or full sheet.
Pound Cake	$21.25 – $144.95	Your choice 2 lb, 3 lb, 4 lb, 5 lb, 1/4 sheet, 1/2 sheet or full sheet.
Chocolate Raspberry Pound Cake	$22.95 – $144.95	Your choice 2 lb, 3 lb, 4 lb, 5 lb, 1/4 sheet, 1/2 sheet or full sheet.
Raspberry Pound Cake	$22.95 – $144.95	Your choice 2 lb, 3 lb, 4 lb, 5 lb, 1/4 sheet, 1/2 sheet or full sheet.
Marble Pound Cake	$22.95 – $144.95	Your choice 2 lb, 3 lb, 4 lb, 5 lb, 1/4 sheet, 1/2 sheet or full sheet.
Vanilla Ricotta Cake	$30.99 – $235.75	Your choie of 8″, 9″ 10″, 12″, 14″, 1/4 sheet, 1/2 sheet or full sheet.
Vanilla PB Ganache Cake	$30.99 – $235.75	Your choie of 8″, 9″ 10″, 12″, 14″, 1/4 sheet, 1/2 sheet or full sheet.
Chocolate Ricotta Cake	$34.00 – $241.50	Your choie of 8″, 10″, 12″, 14″, 1/4 sheet, 1/2 sheet or full sheet.
Chocolate PB Ganache Cake	$34.00 – $241.50	Your choie of 8″, 10″, 12″, 14″, 1/4 sheet, 1/2 sheet or full sheet.
Vanilla SBS Cake	$22.95 – $189.75	Your choie of 7″, 8″, 9″, 10″, 12″, 1/4 sheet, 1/2 sheet or full sheet.
Vanilla Carrot Cake	$22.95 – $189.75	Your choie of 7″, 8″, 9″, 10″, 12″, 1/4 sheet, 1/2 sheet or full sheet.
Chocolate SBS Cake	$24.95 – $202.50	Your choie of 7″, 8″, 10″, 12″, 1/4 sheet, 1/2 sheet or full sheet.
Chocolate Carrot Cake	$24.95 – $202.50	Your choie of 7″, 8″, 10″, 12″, 1/4 sheet, 1/2 sheet or full sheet.
Vanilla Layer Cake	$17.25 – $202.50	Your choie of 7″, 8″, 10″, 12″, 1/4 sheet, 1/2 sheet or full sheet.
Chocolate Layer Cake	$18.50 – $112.50	Your choie of 7″, 8″, 10″, 12″, 1/4 sheet, 1/2 sheet or full sheet.
Carriage Cake	$171.50	Serves 30-40.
5 Tier Cake	$1495.00	Serves 225-250.
Hand Bag	$454.25	Serves 30-40.
Small Hand Bag	$224.25

Potito’s Italian American Pastries Menu : Specialty Cakes

Specialty Cakes

Pb Ganache	$22.95 – $39.75	Your choice of a 7″ or 10″.
Choc. Mousse	$22.95 – $39.75	Your choice of a 7″ or 10″.
Key Lime Tart	$22.95 – $39.75	Your choice of a 7″ or 10″.
Orange Creamsicle	$22.95 – $39.75	Your choice of a 7″ or 10″.
Oreo Cake	$22.95 – $39.75	Your choice of a 7″ or 10″.
Snickers Cake	$22.95 – $39.75	Your choice of a 7″ or 10″.
White Choc. Mousse	$22.95 – $39.75	Your choice of a 7″ or 10″.
Tiramisu	$26.50	7″.

Potito’s Italian American Pastries Menu : Loaf Cake

Loaf Cake

Iced Pound Loaf	$11.50
Pound Loaf	$10.50
Triangle Loaf Cake	$8.00
Chocolate Loaf Cake	$9.25

Potito’s Italian American Pastries Menu : Coffee Cakes

Coffee Cakes

Apple Fritter Coffee Cake	$1.25
Cinnamon Buns Coffee Cake	$1.25
Crumb Cake Coffee Cake	$1.25
Cupcakes Coffee Cake	$1.25
Danish Coffee Cake	$1.50
Danish with Nuts/Coconut Coffee Cake	$2.25
Donuts Coffee Cake	$1.25
Lemon Coconut Coffee Cake	$1.25
Lemon/Jelly Sticks Coffee Cake	$1.25
Tea Biscuits Coffee Cake	$1.25

Potito’s Italian American Pastries Menu : Pies

Pies

Banana Cream Pie	$12.75 – $22.95	Your choice of small or large.
Choc. Ban. Cream Pie	$13.75 – $22.95	Your choice of small or large.
Coconut Custard Pie	$10.50 – $20.75	Your choice of small or large.
Fruit (Plain/Crumb) Pie	$9.75 – $19.50	Your choice of small or large.
Lemon Meringue Pie	$11.50 – $22.95	Your choice of small or large.
Pumpkin Pie	$10.50 – $20.75	Your choice of small or large.

Potito’s Italian American Pastries Menu : Specialties

Specialties

Basinet	$171.50	Serves 40-50.
Upscale 3D Cross	$228.95 – $343.95	Your choice of a 1/2 sheet or full sheet.
Cupcake Tower	$51.75 – $57.50	Your choice of 36 or 48.

Potito’s Italian American Pastries Menu : Chip and Dip Trays

Chip and Dip Trays

$28.75 – $44.95

Your choice of small, medium, or large.

Potito’s Italian American Pastries Menu : Beverages

Beverages

Dasani Bottled Water (.5 L)	$1.85
COKE (12 OZ CAN)	$1.50
DIET COKE (12 OZ. CAN)	$1.50
SEAGRAMS GINGER ALE (12 OZ. CAN)	$1.50
Fuze Iced Tea (12 0Z CAN)	$1.50
12 Pack of Coca-Cola	$18.00
12 Pack of Diet Coke	$18.00
6 Pack of Diet Coke and a 6 Pack of Coke	$18.00
Eco-Friendly Plate & Utensil Kit	$0.40
Eco-Friendly Plates	$0.25
Eco-Friendly Utensils	$0.15
Eco-Friendly Large Catering Tongs	$0.50
Tablecloth	$3.00
6 Cans of Coke	$9.00
6 Cans of Diet Coke	$9.00
6 Cans of Ginger Ale	$9.00
6 Bottles of Water	$9.00

* Disclaimer: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.