Pumpernickel Menu and Prices

Research and order delicious food from the up-to-date Pumpernickel menu. Find latest deals, prices, kid’s meals and more. Pick-up and delivery options available. Browse the whole menu or use our quick jump guide to go directly to the type section of the menu that you are looking for.

Pumpernickel Menu : Steaks

First choose your steak, then choose your style
Grilled NY Strip $23.00
Skirt Steak $22.00 100% Certified Angus Beef
Steak Style – Diner Style   Served with french fries and daily vegetable
Steak Style – South Beach   Pico de gallo and side garden salad
Steak Style – Churrasco $2.00 Madrid sauce (parsley & garlic sauce), rice, and vegetable
Steak Style – Pizzaiola $3.00 Red wine tomato sauce, onions, sweet bell peppers, garlic and crushed red pepper served with rice.
Steak Style – Chicago $3.00 Smothered with grilled onions, mushrooms, and gorgonzola cheese. Served with roasted potato
BBQ Baby Back Ribs $20.00 – $15.00 Slow roast pork ribs covered with our Kansas City style BBQ sauce and char grilled to perfection. Served with coleslaw and sweet potato fries.

Pumpernickel Menu : Starters

Small 1-2 people, large 3-4 people.
Chicken Tenders $8.00 – $14.00 Served w/honey mustard dipping sauce.
Fried Calamari $8.00 – $14.00 W/marinara sauce & lemon wedge.
Fried Ravioli $8.00 – $14.00 W/ marinara sauce.
Mozzarella Sticks $8.00 – $14.00 Served w/ fresh marinara.
Buffalo Style Chicken Tenders $8.50 – $15.00 Served w/ bleu cheese dipping sauce.
Spinach and Artichoke Dip $8.50 – $15.00 Served w/ toast crisps.
Loaded Potato Skins $8.50 – $15.00 Twice baked idaho potatoes loaded with hickory smoked bacon & three cheeses served w/ side of sour cream.
Pumpernickel Sampler $15.00 Mozzarella sticks, buffalo wings, bbq ribs & freaky fried onions.
Italian Combo $16.00 Tender calamari, fried ravioli, mozzarella sticks and parmesan chicken tenders served w/ our homemade marinara dipping sauce.
PEI Mussels $7.00 – $11.00 Choose From 5 sauces: Pumpernickel (steamed w/white wine, tomatoes, jalapeno & cilantro) Marinara or Fra Diavolo (sauce made from scratch, we use only imported plum tomatoes, fresh basil & italian sp
Wings $9.00 – $26.00 (Buffalo style or boneless nickel nuggets) served w/ celery & carrot sticks Buffalo, honey buffalo, teriyaki, bbq, cajun dry rub (spicy only) Bleu cheese dressing or avocado ranch sauce on request Ex

Pumpernickel Menu : Homemade Soup & Chili

French Onion Soup $6.50 Made from scratch, topped w/ toasted croutons & melted swiss cheese.
Daily Soup $5.00 Ask your server about today’s selection. Some chowders priced higher.
Turkey Chili $8.50 Northern white beans, creamy cheddar sauce, country style guacamole & cilantro served w/ tortilla chips.
Cashew Chili $9.00 Award winning vegetarian chili served w/ tortilla chips.
Pumpernickel Chili $8.50 Beef, beer & sausage, chili, melted cheddar, guacamole & sour cream served w/ tortilla chips.

Pumpernickel Menu : From The Field

Add tuna salad or chicken breast $3.75, tequila lime chicken $4.50, salmon or steak $7.00, jumbo shrimp or ahi tuna $8.00, served grilled or blackened.
Garden Salad $5.00 – $8.00 Mixed field greens, tomato, cucumber & onion served w/ choice of dressing.
Traditional Caesar Salad $6.00 – $9.00 Chopped romaine lettuce tossed w/ creamy caesar dressing, baked croutons and aged parmesan.
Harvest Salad $8.00 – $11.00 Pears, gorgonzola cheese & candied walnuts w/ our signature poppy seed dressing over mixed field greens.
Mediterranean Salad $7.00 – $10.00 Marinated chickpeas, tomatoes, cucumbers, artichokes & red onion in a red wine vinaigrette topped w/ feta over mixed field greens.
South Western Salad $8.00 – $11.00 Black bean & corn marinade w/ avocado & mangos served w/ honey mustard dressing over mixed field greens.
Roasted Beet Salad $11.00 Crumbled gorgonzola & tossed field greens, roasted beets, burgundy poached pears & baked apples over mixed field greens tossed w/ our signature sweet poppy dressing.
Blackened Chicken & Fresh Orange Salad $15.00 Fresh cut california style spinach & chopped florida oranges tossed w/ almonds & our homemade honey orange dressing topped w/ blackened chicken breast.

Pumpernickel Menu : Handcrafted Burgers

Classic Burger $9.00 Choose beef, turkey or grilled chicken. served plain w/ french fries, cole slaw and pickle. We will gladly substitute a side garden salad & choice of bread on request.
Classic Cheese Burger $10.50 (American, swiss, cheddar, mozzarella, cheddar-jack) add to any above tomato, lettuce, raw onion $0.25, grilled, frizzled or freaky onions, grilled mushrooms, hot cherry peppers, sliced jalapeños, fr
Pumpernickel Burger Deluxe $11.00 Lettuce, tomato & freaky fried onions on toasted bun w/ french fries.
Old Fashioned Burger $11.00 Grilled onions smashed right into our seasoned burger w/ lettuce, tomato, mayo & pickle on toasted white bread served w/ stixx fries.
Hamburger Club $15.00 Hickory smoked bacon, lettuce, tomato, red onion & mayo on toasted pumpernickel w/ french fries.
California Veggie Burger (No Bun) $12.00 Homemade brown rice veggie burger served w/side southwestern salad, (no fries) choice of bread on request.
Not Just A Turkey Burger $11.00 Served w/ sliced avocado, lettuce, tomato & fripps.
Black & Bleu Burger $11.00 Topped w/ imported gorgonzola served w/ french fries.
Cow Girl Burger $12.00 Hickory smoked bacon, Kansas city style BBQ sauce & grilled onions served w/ french fries.
Chef’s Burger $14.00 Swiss cheese, red onion marmalade, field greens, hot cherry peppers, ffo & sweet potato fries.
Cubano Burger $12.00 Ground beef & chorizo sausage blend, ham, swiss, pickles & mustard sauce served w/ french fries.
Inside Out Burger $12.00 Our jumbo burger stuffed w/red bell pepper & cheddar jack served w/ stixx fries.
Knife And Fork Burger $15.00 Two 1/4 pound burgers, served open faced topped w/house made chili, melted cheddar jack cheese sauce, chopped onions & hot cherry peppers served w/ fries.
Onion Lover’s Burger $12.00 Topped w/ frizzled onions, chef’s sweet onion marmalade, sliced red onion & chopped scallions served w/ french fries.
Stuffed Turkey Burger (No Bun) $13.00 Stuffed w/ apple raisin stuffing & whole berry cranberry relish, topped the same way w/turkey sage gravy & sweet potato fries.
Ahi Tuna Steak Burger $16.00 Seared tuna steak w/ spicy wasabi infused guacamole & bok choy slaw served w/ fripps.
Bourbon Street Burger $14.00 Our hand formed beef burger topped w/ chef’s secret bourbon sauce, swiss cheese, grilled mushrooms & bacon served w/ fries.
Tucson Turkey Burger $13.00 Granny Smith apple, honey mustard sauce, cheddar, hickory smoked bacon, lettuce & tomato served w/ fripps.
Hippie Fish Burger $14.00 Cajun tilapia filet w/ sliced avocado, tomato, red onions, bourbon mayo & bok choy slaw served w/ fripps.
Al’s Jalapeno Burger $13.00 Jalapenos mixed right into the burger topped w/ mozzarella cheese, hot pepper flakes & sliced avocados served w/ french fries.
Dirty Licious Burger $14.00 Blackened cajun burger w/ bbq pulled pork, sliced tomato & freaky fried onions, served w/ sweet potato fries.

Pumpernickel Menu : Entrees

Grilled Veggie Plate $16.00 Chef’s choice fresh market vegetables, toasted pine nuts, shaved parmesan & basil pesto served w/ warm pita bread.
Blackened Chicken $16.00 Hand trimmed marinated chicken breast served w/ rice and daily vegetable.
Herb Roasted Chicken $15.00 Baked 1/2 chicken served w/ roasted potato & daily vegetable.
Penne Vodka $14.00 Fresh herbs, sweet peas, shallots & parma style prosciutto in a creamy marinara sauce.
Spinach & Chicken $15.00 Fresh cut california style spinach & chicken breast sauteed in garlic & oil over linguine.
Linguine Bolognese $16.00 Slow simmered beef & pork ragu made w/ imported italian tomatoes, fresh herbs & a touch of cream.
Fettuccine Chicken Gardenia $17.00 Fresh chopped tomato, artichokes, chicken breast, basil & roasted peppers sauteed in garlic and oil.

Pumpernickel Menu : Seafood

Pan Seared Salmon $19.00 North atlantic salmon filet served w/ roasted potato, vegetable & lemon butter sauce.
Bourbon Glazed Salmon $20.00 Served w/ rice & daily vegetable.
Pan Seared Tilapia Filet $16.00 Served w/ rice, vegetable & lemon butter sauce.
Southwest Tilapia $17.00 Cajun spiced blackened tilapia w/ fresh mango salsa & small southwest salad.
Steak & Shrimp Combo $24.00 Grilled jumbo shrimp and half order 100% cab skirt steak served w/ rice & daily vegetable.
Seafood Fra Diavolo $21.00 Gulf shrimp, pei mussels, calamari & fresh atlantic salmon in a spicy marinara sauce over linguine.

Pumpernickel Menu : Nachos & Quesadillas

Bar Size Nachos $9.00 (1 to 2 People).
Table Size Nachos $13.00 (3 to 4 People). Tortilla chips topped w/ pumpernickel chili, hot peppers, melted cheddar sauce, guacamole, salsa & sour cream.
Don Nachos $13.00 Tortilla chips topped w/ tequila-lime chicken, white beans, chef’s cheesy bean sauce, jack cheese, guacamole, cilantro, sour cream & pico de gallo served in a basket.
Rio Rancho Nachos $13.00 Tortilla chips topped w/ turkey chili, creamy white cheese sauce, country style guacamole & cilantro sprinkle.
California Style Nachos $10.00 Tortilla chips topped w/ refried beans, shredded cheese, lettuce, tomato, sour cream cilantro.
Buffalo Nickel Nachos $11.00 Tortilla chips w/ chopped buffalo style nickel nuggets, cheddar, jack & bleu cheese, pico de gallo, sour cream & green onion.
Irish BBQ Nachos $12.00 Slow roasted pulled pork, tomatoes, melted cheddar sauce, hot peppers & sour cream served over fripps (rippled potato chips).
Cheese Quesadilla $9.00 Flour tortilla filled w/three cheeses, served w/ guacamole, pico di gallo & sour cream. Add chicken $2.00, pulled pork or buffalo chicken $3.00, steak $4.00.
Grilled Veggie Quesadilla $10.00 Whole wheat tortilla filled w/ cheese & mixed grilled vegetables w/ guacamole, pico de gallo & sour cream.
Southwest Quesadilla $12.00 Whole wheat tortilla filled w/ three cheeses, sliced avocado, sweet corn & black bean salsa served w/ pico di gallo & sour cream.

Pumpernickel Menu : Between The Bread

All sandwiches served w/ fries (rippled potato chips) & coleslaw add $1.00 for fries, $2.00 for sweet potato fries.
Not Just A BLT $10.50 Hickory smoked bacon, avocado, lettuce, tomato & mayo on country white.
Pub Pulled Pork $12.00 Slow roasted pork shoulder, freaky fried onions & bbq sauce on a hard roll.
Steak Sandwich $13.50 Tender grilled steak, caramelized onions, melted mozzarella & garlic mayo on a wedge roll.
Manhattan Deli Sandwich $20.00 Corned beef, grilled pastrami & Swiss piled high on this huge triple decker sandwich served w/ coleslaw and pickle on rye.
Pumpernickel Reuben $13.50 Choose corned beef, roasted turkey breast or pastrami, melted swiss, coleslaw & russian dressing on pumpernickel.
Garden Veggie Reuben $13.50 Grilled squash, zucchini, roasted peppers, warm jicama pear slaw, melted swiss on pumpernickel.
Turkey Club $13.00 Roasted turkey breast, hickory smoked bacon, lettuce, tomato & mayo on toasted country white.
Tuna Salad $10.50 Made from all white meat albacore w/ lettuce & tomato on country white.
Homemade Greek Gyro $13.00 Fresh seasoned ground beef & pork gyro, lettuce, tomato, red onion & tzatziki sauce served in a warm pita.
Chicken Souvlaki $13.00 Marinated chicken breast, lettuce, tomato, cucumber, red onion,tzatziki sauce served in a warm pita.
Cheesy Cheddar Steak Wrap $16.00 Tender grilled steak, sautéed onions, cheddar cheese & sliced avocado in a whole wheat wrap.
Grilled Veggie Wrap $10.00 Chef selection of seasonal vegetables, mozzarella cheese & roasted peppers in a whole wheat wrap.
Wild Turkey Wrap $12.00 Roasted turkey breast, sliced apple, mixed field greens & honey mustard sauce in a white wrap.
Chicken Caesar Wrap $12.00 Grilled chicken breast, chopped romaine lettuce, aged parmesan & creamy caesar dressing rolled in a white wrap.
Buffalo Wrap $12.00 Chopped buffalo style chicken breast, mixed field greens & freaky fried onions in a white wrap.
Pumpernickel Chicken Club $15.00 Grilled chicken, hickory smoked bacon, lettuce, tomato, avocado & russian dressing on toasted pumpernickel.
Grilled Salmon BLT $16.00 We added grilled salmon filet, fresh basil pesto & sliced avocado to this classic on toasted pumpernickel.

Pumpernickel Menu : Sliders

(Each order served w/ 3 sliders & french fries) served medium temperature and above only.
Original Aged Cheddar $12.00
Original Classic $11.00 W/ lettuce & tomato.
Italian Grilled Chicken $14.00 Sliced tomato, melted mozzarella & fresh basil.
Chicken Parmigiana $13.00 Served w/ side of homemade marinara.
Meatball Parmigiana $12.00 Served w/ side of homemade marinara.
BBQ Turkey $13.00 Grilled onions, hickory smoked bacon & kansas city bbq sauce.
BBQ Pulled Pork $13.00 Slow roasted pork shoulder w/ kansas city bbq sauce & ffo.
Chicken BLT $14.00 Grilled chicken breast, hickory smoked bacon, lettuce, tomato & mayo.
Meatloaf $12.00 W/ grilled mushrooms & brown gravy.

Pumpernickel Menu : Melts

Lower East Side $16.00 Hand formed jumbo beef burger, grilled pastrami, melted swiss & coleslaw on grilled rye bread served w/ fries.
Big Texas BBQ $16.00 100% Certified angus steak, aged cheddar, grilled onions and kansas city style bbq sauce on grilled texas toast served w/ fripps.
Arizona Chicken $13.00 Grilled chicken breast, granny smith apple, aged cheddar, hickory smoked bacon w/ honey mustard on grilled pumpernickel served w/ fripps.
Super Grilled Cheese $10.50 French brie, aged cheddar & havarti w/ sliced tomato on grilled pumpernickel served w/ fripps.
Bacon Mushroom Chicken $13.00 Grilled chicken breast, hickory smoked bacon, mushrooms, onions & melted swiss on grilled rye w/ fripps.
Bourbon Chicken $14.00 Grilled chicken breast, aged cheddar, gorgonzola, bacon, & bourbon sauce on grilled texas toast served w/ fripps.

Pumpernickel Menu : Baskets

Served w/ french fries. All of our fried baskets are prepared in house, minimally processed and trans fat free.
Pub Style Fish & Fripps $16.00 Hand dipped battered tilapia filet, tartar sauce & lemon wedge.
Fried Shrimp $17.00 Panko crusted shrimp, tartar sauce & lemon wedge.
Fried Calamari $16.00 W/ marinara sauce & lemon wedge.
Fried Clams $16.00 Cut whole belly clam strips, tartar sauce & lemon wedge.
Shrimp & Tenders $15.00 Handcut chicken tenders & fried shrimp served w/ honey orange dipping sauce.
Cajun Wings $13.00 Cajun dry rubbed chicken wings served w/ avocado-ranch dipping sauce.
Chicken Tenders $14.00 Served w/ honey mustard dipping sauce.
Pee Wee Grande $13.00 Mini hot dogs baked in puff pastry.

Pumpernickel Menu : Comfort Food

Baked Macaroni & Cheese $12.00 The ultimate comfort food made w/ a creamy asiago, swiss & cheddar cheese sauce & topped w/ baked panko breadcrumbs.
Smothered Fried Chicken $16.00 Half fried chicken smothered in southern style gravy served w/ mashed potatoes & vegetable.
Baked Penne $14.00 Slow baked in our homemade cheesy cream sauce, w/ chopped meatballs, sweet italian sausage and mozzarella cheese topped w/ toasted panko.
Grandma’s Meatloaf $15.00 Our all beef recipe served w/mashed potatoes, gravy & vegetable.
Hot Open Turkey Sandwich $16.00 Hand carved roasted turkey breast served w/ turkey sage gravy, mashed potatoes & cranberry sauce on country white.
Petite Sliced Steak $17.00 Half order certified Angus skirt steak served w/ mushroom gravy, mashed potatoes & vegetable.
Chicken Parmigiana $16.00 Tender breaded chicken breast, melted mozzarella & homemademarinara sauce served w/ side of pasta.

Pumpernickel Menu : Just For Kids

(Ages up to 12). All meals come w/ juice and fries.
Pasta $5.50 – $7.00 Marinara sauce or butter (add meatballs $2.50) mac & cheese style. (Served without fries).
Grilled Cheese $6.00
Jr Burger (Beef Or Turkey) $6.00
Jr Grilled Chicken Sandwich $6.00 W/ cheese add $1.00.
Chicken Tenders $6.00
Chicken Tenders – Parmigiana Style $8.00
Chicken Tenders – Buffalo Style $8.00
Ravioli $7.50 – $9.00 Mac & cheese style or fried. (Served without fries).
Flat Bread Pizza $7.00 (Add sausage $1.00). (Served without fries).
Pee Wee Basket $7.00 Mini hot dogs baked in rolled pastry dough.
Jr American Combo $8.00 Jr burger and mini hot dogs baked in rolled pastry dough.
Jr Fish Sticks $9.00

* Disclaimer: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

Related Posts